Five

A Novel

Author Ilona Bannister On Tour
Look inside
Hardcover
$28.00 US
| $38.99 CAN
On sale May 05, 2026 | 240 Pages | 9798217088027

See Additional Formats
Five lives. Five stories. Four will live—one will die. Who it will be? In this slow-burn masterpiece of psychological fiction, the choice is all yours.

Five is a gripping, chilling story that asks difficult questions about judgement, forgiveness, and the notion of cause and effect.”—Chris Whitaker, New York Times bestselling author of All the Colors of the Dark

Have you ever tried to pass the time by imagining the lives of the strangers standing next to you? Ilona Bannister’s Five introduces readers to five seemingly random people waiting for a train. But these are not just any five people. From the beginning we know that one of them is going to die soon. Very soon. In five minutes the next train to London will arrive, killing one of them. But before this happens you will learn their stories.

None of these people are saints. Readers might fall in love with the beautiful young man who is on the verge of gambling his life away. They may pity the cantankerous old woman who has fallen to the ground yet is refusing help. Perhaps readers will look away from the child throwing a tantrum. Or judge his mother, who must surely be to blame. And some will be curiously compelled by the successful and damaged businessman orbiting them all.

These are the candidates for this morning’s misfortune. But they don’t know it. Only you know. And you, our complicit reader, will not be able to resist deciding who deserves to walk away, and who deserves only five more minutes to live.

An incredibly original novel that breaks the fourth wall and asks the reader to be judge, jury, and executioner, Five looks at some of the most complicated issues of contemporary life: motherhood, disability, addiction. Every stranger has a story. And in Ilona Bannister’s skillful hands, five people’s stories come together to create an unforgettable novel.
07:01

Someone will die here this morning, at this suburban train station. It will happen in the next five minutes when the 7:06 to London Victoria arrives.

Four others have died here previously. In 1861, an alcoholic mourning his dead wife and child in a stupor of grief. In 1923, a World War I veteran, suffering from shell shock, bombs exploding in his head until his last breath. In 1972, a teenage girl, unmarried and pregnant, forced to leave home by her parents. In 1994, a seeing-eye dog who gave its life to save its owner when he stumbled perilously close to the tracks at just the wrong moment.

At least two of these deaths were accidental, one was intentional, and one seemed intentional but wasn’t, but they will not be described here in detail because we have only a few minutes before the train arrives. And there is a great deal yet to discuss. And a fifth death to witness that may or may not be deliberate. It will be hard to tell when it happens.

Turn your attention now to the stairs descending to the platform. A small child struggles out of his mother’s grasp. He shrieks. He bolts toward the tracks.

He looks over his shoulder and sees his stricken mother, running. He laughs and trots to the edge of the platform. He turns around to face her, his back to the platform edge and the tracks beneath it. He does not realize that he has crossed the yellow caution line. Even if he does realize it, he is too young to understand the yellow line’s warning that another step back will be too far. He steps.

He loses his footing and the platform disappears underneath him. He looks at his mother. As he begins to fall, he meets her eyes and in them he sees something he does not yet have the words to name. It is not anger or fear.

It is hesitation. It would be easier if I lost him, is the thought she thinks for a sliver of a moment, a granule of time, thirty-nine hundredths of a second, to be precise.

Pause here for a moment.

Please do not judge this mother for having this thought. Thoughts like these come to all mothers. They are involuntary. Sometimes they appear precisely because they are the opposite of what the mother truly thinks. The mother’s anxious, exhausted brain plays a sinister game with her. It makes her think that she will say and do things that she would never, ever, say or do.

For example, a mother does not really want to throw her baby out of the third-story window to perish on the pavement below, although she may think this every time the window catches her eye when she passes it, holding her crying infant to her chest and swaying in her reflection in the glass. A mother does not want to push her baby buggy in front of a bus, although the thought flickers across her mind every time she stands at the bus stop, her toddler whining and struggling against the straps of the seat.

A mother’s brain, knowing how much she loves her child, tortures her with that love, inverts her love, turns it inside out with horrible, haunting thoughts of terrible things that she would never do and that will never happen to her child. So please, do not think badly of this mother for having this thought in this moment.

It is her thoughts that come after it that should concern you. They’ll say it’s a shame if he falls, she thinks, the next step she takes imperceptibly slower than the last.

They’ll say it was an accident, she thinks, reaching out, but not quite reaching him.

“Oi!” a man shouts on the platform, at 7:01 and seventeen seconds. He is a businessman. A man’s man, a macho man, a family man, a self-made man, whatta man, whatta man, whatta man, whatta might—

“Oi!” the man shouts as he runs up to the mother and grabs her by the elbow, helping her regain her balance as she in turn grabs her son by the shoulders of his coat. The man pulls the mother with her child from the platform edge. “Careful now,” he says.

The boy, Gideon, does not say anything. His mother, Emma, thinks, F***, and says, “What are you doing here?” quietly. She does not look him in the eye. Breathless, she puts a protective arm around her son’s shoulders, adjusts her bag with her other hand, bends to hoist him onto her hip, and struggles because of their bulky coats and because he is six years old and too big for her to carry. The skin on the knuckles of her ungloved hand is cracked and bleeding. From the cold gray air of this morning. From the mother’s work that she does.

Emma says, softly, seriously, “Why are you here?” as Gideon pulls the hat off her head and throws it on the ground and screams. He kicks away from her. She puts him down but grasps his arm tightly, forcefully. “Gideon,” she says sharply through clenched teeth.

“Here you go,” the man says, picking up the hat. “One of those mornings, eh?” he says, and he shrugs with a friendly smile.

Emma says nothing. He is speaking to her like they’re friends, like colleagues on good terms, and not each other’s downfall. How much simpler, better, her life would have been if she had never met, never known, this man.

“Did you follow me?” she asks.

“Should I have a little chat with ’im?” the businessman says to her in a lower voice, ignoring her question. “Tell the boy to give ’is mum a break—”

Emma grabs the hat, briefly looking the man in the eye, and says, “No. I’m trying to do what you want. I need time.”

The businessman steps back. “Look, forget about yesterday. Just hear me out,” he says. “And you,” he crouches down to be on Gideon’s eye level, “you be good for your mum.” Standing he says to Emma, “He’s just like my others, full of beans.”

Except that Gideon is nothing like his “others,” the other six children of the businessman. The two youngest of whom are boys, a little older than Gideon, the result of his third marriage to a much younger woman who will be dropping them off at school about twenty-five minutes after the death in their brand-new G-Wagon. They are well adjusted and rosy-cheeked, and the young wife will tell them that she loves them when she leaves them and then drives away to start her day with Pilates, then the PTA fundraiser meeting, then walking the dog and shopping online before she picks them up from after-school football or drama or how-to-grow-up-to-be-just-like-your-asshole-rich-dad training. Emma would like to tell his wife to f*** off and die. She would like to tell all the wives like the businessman’s wife to f*** off and die.

She would like to get away from the businessman now, she would like for him not to look at her and her son and make assumptions.

“I’m working on your brother,” she says to the businessman. “But I can’t talk about it now.”

Emma then turns abruptly with Gideon and moves to a bench further down the platform. She doesn’t care if the businessman thinks she’s a bitch. Their exchange lasts twenty-seven seconds.

Bitch, the businessman thinks for sixteen hundredths of a second as she leaves. He watches Emma and her son walk down the platform. He considers his next move. Emma is skittish and he had hoped she’d behave herself in a public place. He scared her yesterday. He shouldn’t have done that. He just wants her to smooth it over with his brother. Then put their pooled money into the start-up he’s funding today—a project with lifesaving potential on a world-changing scale—and forget all of this when they’re rolling in it. That’s all. Money fixes everything. Which is why the businessman is confused by Emma’s reaction because usually women listen to him. Usually women love him. Well, perhaps not all women.

For example, the slender, elderly white woman with the short white hair who is watching him and Emma right now would definitely not love him if she met him. The businessman, admittedly, does not do well with her demographic, as he is only interested in women who are f***able, so he has not noticed her this morning. And this is just as well because the old woman, Mrs. Worth, does not want to be noticed. And she certainly doesn’t want to be f***ed. Not this morning. She is standing in her long black coat, collar up against the wind, at the far end of the platform where the sign warns, “Passengers must not pass this point or cross the line.”

During the twenty-seven seconds of the businessman and Emma’s conversation, Mrs. Worth was lighting a surreptitious cigarette. She knows no one is watching her because it is early in the morning and no one cares about the activities of old women, and she also doesn’t give a goddamn if they do. She is nervous. It is an important day.

Mrs. Worth takes her second drag and enjoys judging Emma, who is now on a bench furiously taking things out of her bag, looking for something.
“Ridiculously good!! Razor-sharp, wickedly funny, and darkly thrilling. Five is a gripping, chilling story that asks difficult questions about judgement, forgiveness, and the notion of cause and effect. Unforgettable.”—Chris Whitaker, New York Times bestselling author of All the Colors of the Dark

“Propulsive, sharp, and ferociously addictive, Five is one of the most original novels I’ve read in years. I devoured it quickly, but I can’t stop thinking about this story. Ilona Bannister is such a talent.”—Alafair Burke, New York Times bestselling author of The Note and The Better Sister

“Ilona Bannister has written a riveting, ticking time bomb of a novel. Five is brilliant: a gripping tour de force about destiny and choice—and, yes, an oncoming train. I devoured it. You will, too.”—Chris Bohjalian, #1 New York Times bestselling author

“Viscerally insightful, emotionally punchy, wryly observed, and with scalpel-precision writing, Five is a tour de force of a novel. I read it in one sitting. Bravo!”—Sarah Pinborough, New York Times bestselling author of Behind Her Eyes and We Live Here Now

“Original. Urgent. Disturbing. Brilliant. Quite unlike anything I’ve ever read. Don’t miss this one—Ilona Bannister is a major talent.”—Shari Lapena, New York Times bestselling author of The Couple Next Door and She Didn’t See It Coming

Five is twisty, inventive, and dark as a subway tunnel. Bannister dissects the thriller trope with a meta-edged scalpel, divulging to the reader the dubious morality inside each of her characters and asking us to weigh the scales of our empathy as we discover who lives, who dies, and—to our horror—how we might have chosen differently.”—Philip Fracassi, author of The Autumn Springs Retirement Home Massacre

“This is not your average whodunit . . . [A] tense, deftly written page-turner filled with memorable characters, a surprisingly philosophical core, and a plot in which each minute brings a new surprise . . . [C]lever and incisive writing and the unique format make readers participants in the action and complicit in weighing the characters’ worthiness. It’s unsettling and immersive.”Kirkus Reviews, starred review

“[A] sharply observed suspense novel from Bannister . . . [her] compassion and gift for nerve-shredding tension make this a ride worth taking.”Publishers Weekly

“Bannister writes a morbidly entertaining story about deeply unlikable characters and the familial trauma that brings them all together. Her choice to break the fourth wall is a clever way to tell a story that only takes place over the span of about five minutes . . . for fans of intense psychological thrillers.”Booklist
© Timothy L. Bannister
Ilona Bannister, born and raised in New York, lives in the UK with her husband and sons. Her first book, When I Ran Away, was longlisted for the Center for Fiction's First Novel Prize. View titles by Ilona Bannister

About

Five lives. Five stories. Four will live—one will die. Who it will be? In this slow-burn masterpiece of psychological fiction, the choice is all yours.

Five is a gripping, chilling story that asks difficult questions about judgement, forgiveness, and the notion of cause and effect.”—Chris Whitaker, New York Times bestselling author of All the Colors of the Dark

Have you ever tried to pass the time by imagining the lives of the strangers standing next to you? Ilona Bannister’s Five introduces readers to five seemingly random people waiting for a train. But these are not just any five people. From the beginning we know that one of them is going to die soon. Very soon. In five minutes the next train to London will arrive, killing one of them. But before this happens you will learn their stories.

None of these people are saints. Readers might fall in love with the beautiful young man who is on the verge of gambling his life away. They may pity the cantankerous old woman who has fallen to the ground yet is refusing help. Perhaps readers will look away from the child throwing a tantrum. Or judge his mother, who must surely be to blame. And some will be curiously compelled by the successful and damaged businessman orbiting them all.

These are the candidates for this morning’s misfortune. But they don’t know it. Only you know. And you, our complicit reader, will not be able to resist deciding who deserves to walk away, and who deserves only five more minutes to live.

An incredibly original novel that breaks the fourth wall and asks the reader to be judge, jury, and executioner, Five looks at some of the most complicated issues of contemporary life: motherhood, disability, addiction. Every stranger has a story. And in Ilona Bannister’s skillful hands, five people’s stories come together to create an unforgettable novel.

Excerpt

07:01

Someone will die here this morning, at this suburban train station. It will happen in the next five minutes when the 7:06 to London Victoria arrives.

Four others have died here previously. In 1861, an alcoholic mourning his dead wife and child in a stupor of grief. In 1923, a World War I veteran, suffering from shell shock, bombs exploding in his head until his last breath. In 1972, a teenage girl, unmarried and pregnant, forced to leave home by her parents. In 1994, a seeing-eye dog who gave its life to save its owner when he stumbled perilously close to the tracks at just the wrong moment.

At least two of these deaths were accidental, one was intentional, and one seemed intentional but wasn’t, but they will not be described here in detail because we have only a few minutes before the train arrives. And there is a great deal yet to discuss. And a fifth death to witness that may or may not be deliberate. It will be hard to tell when it happens.

Turn your attention now to the stairs descending to the platform. A small child struggles out of his mother’s grasp. He shrieks. He bolts toward the tracks.

He looks over his shoulder and sees his stricken mother, running. He laughs and trots to the edge of the platform. He turns around to face her, his back to the platform edge and the tracks beneath it. He does not realize that he has crossed the yellow caution line. Even if he does realize it, he is too young to understand the yellow line’s warning that another step back will be too far. He steps.

He loses his footing and the platform disappears underneath him. He looks at his mother. As he begins to fall, he meets her eyes and in them he sees something he does not yet have the words to name. It is not anger or fear.

It is hesitation. It would be easier if I lost him, is the thought she thinks for a sliver of a moment, a granule of time, thirty-nine hundredths of a second, to be precise.

Pause here for a moment.

Please do not judge this mother for having this thought. Thoughts like these come to all mothers. They are involuntary. Sometimes they appear precisely because they are the opposite of what the mother truly thinks. The mother’s anxious, exhausted brain plays a sinister game with her. It makes her think that she will say and do things that she would never, ever, say or do.

For example, a mother does not really want to throw her baby out of the third-story window to perish on the pavement below, although she may think this every time the window catches her eye when she passes it, holding her crying infant to her chest and swaying in her reflection in the glass. A mother does not want to push her baby buggy in front of a bus, although the thought flickers across her mind every time she stands at the bus stop, her toddler whining and struggling against the straps of the seat.

A mother’s brain, knowing how much she loves her child, tortures her with that love, inverts her love, turns it inside out with horrible, haunting thoughts of terrible things that she would never do and that will never happen to her child. So please, do not think badly of this mother for having this thought in this moment.

It is her thoughts that come after it that should concern you. They’ll say it’s a shame if he falls, she thinks, the next step she takes imperceptibly slower than the last.

They’ll say it was an accident, she thinks, reaching out, but not quite reaching him.

“Oi!” a man shouts on the platform, at 7:01 and seventeen seconds. He is a businessman. A man’s man, a macho man, a family man, a self-made man, whatta man, whatta man, whatta man, whatta might—

“Oi!” the man shouts as he runs up to the mother and grabs her by the elbow, helping her regain her balance as she in turn grabs her son by the shoulders of his coat. The man pulls the mother with her child from the platform edge. “Careful now,” he says.

The boy, Gideon, does not say anything. His mother, Emma, thinks, F***, and says, “What are you doing here?” quietly. She does not look him in the eye. Breathless, she puts a protective arm around her son’s shoulders, adjusts her bag with her other hand, bends to hoist him onto her hip, and struggles because of their bulky coats and because he is six years old and too big for her to carry. The skin on the knuckles of her ungloved hand is cracked and bleeding. From the cold gray air of this morning. From the mother’s work that she does.

Emma says, softly, seriously, “Why are you here?” as Gideon pulls the hat off her head and throws it on the ground and screams. He kicks away from her. She puts him down but grasps his arm tightly, forcefully. “Gideon,” she says sharply through clenched teeth.

“Here you go,” the man says, picking up the hat. “One of those mornings, eh?” he says, and he shrugs with a friendly smile.

Emma says nothing. He is speaking to her like they’re friends, like colleagues on good terms, and not each other’s downfall. How much simpler, better, her life would have been if she had never met, never known, this man.

“Did you follow me?” she asks.

“Should I have a little chat with ’im?” the businessman says to her in a lower voice, ignoring her question. “Tell the boy to give ’is mum a break—”

Emma grabs the hat, briefly looking the man in the eye, and says, “No. I’m trying to do what you want. I need time.”

The businessman steps back. “Look, forget about yesterday. Just hear me out,” he says. “And you,” he crouches down to be on Gideon’s eye level, “you be good for your mum.” Standing he says to Emma, “He’s just like my others, full of beans.”

Except that Gideon is nothing like his “others,” the other six children of the businessman. The two youngest of whom are boys, a little older than Gideon, the result of his third marriage to a much younger woman who will be dropping them off at school about twenty-five minutes after the death in their brand-new G-Wagon. They are well adjusted and rosy-cheeked, and the young wife will tell them that she loves them when she leaves them and then drives away to start her day with Pilates, then the PTA fundraiser meeting, then walking the dog and shopping online before she picks them up from after-school football or drama or how-to-grow-up-to-be-just-like-your-asshole-rich-dad training. Emma would like to tell his wife to f*** off and die. She would like to tell all the wives like the businessman’s wife to f*** off and die.

She would like to get away from the businessman now, she would like for him not to look at her and her son and make assumptions.

“I’m working on your brother,” she says to the businessman. “But I can’t talk about it now.”

Emma then turns abruptly with Gideon and moves to a bench further down the platform. She doesn’t care if the businessman thinks she’s a bitch. Their exchange lasts twenty-seven seconds.

Bitch, the businessman thinks for sixteen hundredths of a second as she leaves. He watches Emma and her son walk down the platform. He considers his next move. Emma is skittish and he had hoped she’d behave herself in a public place. He scared her yesterday. He shouldn’t have done that. He just wants her to smooth it over with his brother. Then put their pooled money into the start-up he’s funding today—a project with lifesaving potential on a world-changing scale—and forget all of this when they’re rolling in it. That’s all. Money fixes everything. Which is why the businessman is confused by Emma’s reaction because usually women listen to him. Usually women love him. Well, perhaps not all women.

For example, the slender, elderly white woman with the short white hair who is watching him and Emma right now would definitely not love him if she met him. The businessman, admittedly, does not do well with her demographic, as he is only interested in women who are f***able, so he has not noticed her this morning. And this is just as well because the old woman, Mrs. Worth, does not want to be noticed. And she certainly doesn’t want to be f***ed. Not this morning. She is standing in her long black coat, collar up against the wind, at the far end of the platform where the sign warns, “Passengers must not pass this point or cross the line.”

During the twenty-seven seconds of the businessman and Emma’s conversation, Mrs. Worth was lighting a surreptitious cigarette. She knows no one is watching her because it is early in the morning and no one cares about the activities of old women, and she also doesn’t give a goddamn if they do. She is nervous. It is an important day.

Mrs. Worth takes her second drag and enjoys judging Emma, who is now on a bench furiously taking things out of her bag, looking for something.

Reviews

“Ridiculously good!! Razor-sharp, wickedly funny, and darkly thrilling. Five is a gripping, chilling story that asks difficult questions about judgement, forgiveness, and the notion of cause and effect. Unforgettable.”—Chris Whitaker, New York Times bestselling author of All the Colors of the Dark

“Propulsive, sharp, and ferociously addictive, Five is one of the most original novels I’ve read in years. I devoured it quickly, but I can’t stop thinking about this story. Ilona Bannister is such a talent.”—Alafair Burke, New York Times bestselling author of The Note and The Better Sister

“Ilona Bannister has written a riveting, ticking time bomb of a novel. Five is brilliant: a gripping tour de force about destiny and choice—and, yes, an oncoming train. I devoured it. You will, too.”—Chris Bohjalian, #1 New York Times bestselling author

“Viscerally insightful, emotionally punchy, wryly observed, and with scalpel-precision writing, Five is a tour de force of a novel. I read it in one sitting. Bravo!”—Sarah Pinborough, New York Times bestselling author of Behind Her Eyes and We Live Here Now

“Original. Urgent. Disturbing. Brilliant. Quite unlike anything I’ve ever read. Don’t miss this one—Ilona Bannister is a major talent.”—Shari Lapena, New York Times bestselling author of The Couple Next Door and She Didn’t See It Coming

Five is twisty, inventive, and dark as a subway tunnel. Bannister dissects the thriller trope with a meta-edged scalpel, divulging to the reader the dubious morality inside each of her characters and asking us to weigh the scales of our empathy as we discover who lives, who dies, and—to our horror—how we might have chosen differently.”—Philip Fracassi, author of The Autumn Springs Retirement Home Massacre

“This is not your average whodunit . . . [A] tense, deftly written page-turner filled with memorable characters, a surprisingly philosophical core, and a plot in which each minute brings a new surprise . . . [C]lever and incisive writing and the unique format make readers participants in the action and complicit in weighing the characters’ worthiness. It’s unsettling and immersive.”Kirkus Reviews, starred review

“[A] sharply observed suspense novel from Bannister . . . [her] compassion and gift for nerve-shredding tension make this a ride worth taking.”Publishers Weekly

“Bannister writes a morbidly entertaining story about deeply unlikable characters and the familial trauma that brings them all together. Her choice to break the fourth wall is a clever way to tell a story that only takes place over the span of about five minutes . . . for fans of intense psychological thrillers.”Booklist

Author

© Timothy L. Bannister
Ilona Bannister, born and raised in New York, lives in the UK with her husband and sons. Her first book, When I Ran Away, was longlisted for the Center for Fiction's First Novel Prize. View titles by Ilona Bannister
  • More Websites from
    Penguin Random House
  • Common Reads
  • Library Marketing